Thanks for your suggestions.
I would propose the following:
1. Keep existing model but make it "SHOULD" for old registrar
of upcoming transfer (I still don't understand how that failed in
panix.com case BTW, because I'm pretty certain dotster does it, the
only thing I can think of is that they did but answer was
all the spam that hostmaster account received).
2. Allow for fast way to reverse the domain transfer for old register.
I'd propose the following:
a. Old registrar can use special registry function to request
reversal within 5 days of the transfer and that is immediatly
granted (no questions asked at that time) with
of old NS servers
Might be better to simply revert the NS records at the request of the
original registrar, and then place the name on registry lock until the
dispute is resolved. Note for URDP disputes a name is typically
locked by a registrar (although the current NS record state is
Most of the other steps regarding provision of evidence and
full-rollback to the original registrar are covered under the existing
transfer dispute policies. The detailed process is documented here: