i am told that the following session has been accepted for the nanog
agenda.
A Comparison of Approaches to Loc/ID, Routing Scaling, and the
Universe
Abstract:
This session looks at and contrasts:
LISP (Dino Farinacci)
ILNP (Saleem Bhatti)
RFC 6296 (Fred Baker)
Where each is explained at an architectural level in some detail
with a predetermined list of questions such as "how does this
address loc/id separation, routing table scaling, incremental
deployment, state of implementation/testing, ..."
And then a half hour where we all sum up the similarities and
differences. Maybe it will be worth writing up.
The goal is education and understanding, not a contest. These are
all good and interesting approaches. Weapons are not allowed, we all
work for the Internet.
as you can see, i am interested in
o loc/id separation
o rounting table scaling
o deployability on the internet
o current state of development
what did i miss? what major attributes interest you?
o Trust model (how much trust is put in whom so that connectivity works)
o How much state where
o Security implications (where are the weak links, vectors for attack)
o Traffic engineering (ingress and egress) features
o Session survivability on rerouting (manual and due to outages)
- complexity (define a metric [eek!] ...)
- overhead (who, what, where, why..[closely tied with the "state" question])
- who benefits and who pays? endpoints? backbones ISPs in the DFZ?
SMB? Enterprises? Router companies? ... it's like Lenin said, you
look for the person who will benefit and...
o Trust model (how much trust is put in whom so that connectivity works)
o How much state where
o Security implications (where are the weak links, vectors for attack)
o Traffic engineering (ingress and egress) features
o Session survivability on rerouting (manual and due to outages)
- complexity (define a metric [eek!] ...)
good luck with that one
- overhead (who, what, where, why..[closely tied with the "state"
question])
- who benefits and who pays? endpoints? backbones ISPs in the DFZ?
SMB? Enterprises? Router companies? ... it's like Lenin said, you
look for the person who will benefit and...
i think of this as 'economic model.' what will change from the current
model?