An informal survey... round II

Date: Thu, 30 Aug 2007 10:18:41 -0400
From: Andrew D Kirch <>

John Curran wrote:
>>> I.E. If at some time unknown around 2010, ISP's stop receiving
>>> new allocations from their RIR, and instead use of many smaller
>>> "recycled" IPv4 address blocks, we could be looking at a 10x to
>>> 20x increase in routes per month for the same customer growth.
>> John,
>> Why should we announce tiny recycled blocks? If there is a /16 in the
>> swamp in which half the space is free but its all /24's, why wouldn't
>> wouldn't we allocate all the free /24's to a single entity and
>> instruct the entity to announce it as a "holey" /16? The existing /24
>> holders will override (punch holes in) the /16 for their /24's.
> Consider large ISP's that can no longer obtain from the large blocks
> (e.g. /12 to /16) but instead must beg/barter/borrow blocks from others
> which are several orders of magnitude smaller (e.g. /16 through /24)
> every week to continue growing... such obtained blocks would be
> announced into the routing system very rapidly as we try to keep
> IPv4 running post depletion of the free address pool. When this
> inflection point is reached, how much headroom do we have given
> equipment being deployed today?
> /John
Is there a possible revenue stream here for larger ISP's to begin
charging their customers for not aggregating, and creating a penalty fee
for each borken route? We're running out of IPv4 space (and I don't
think this can be solved with IPv4). We're running out of routes for
the Cisco Sup2 engine (among others), but unless someone makes money on
it, this won't be solved.

When customers start having problems due to router RIB and/or FIB
overflow, they will seek other providers. So someone will make money and
someone else will lose it. Economics works well when things break

Of course, what happens when there is simply no IPv4 space is another
issue as there will be no new space for anyone. But some providers will
run out of their allocations long before others. If those who run out
have resources, the market in IPv4 addresses (which does not exist since
addresses are just numbers and not property) will get very active and
will provide its own incentives which may or may not be stabilizing or