This topic needs a title

Mailman List Mirror (Read Only)
1

Cc
Bcc:
Reply-To:
In-Reply-To: <20090507161041.f1711126.darcy@druid.net>

It is. I understand what they are trying to do but we were cut off
from some places because someone else in the huge upstream we are with
did something that appeared to be spam. It's too broad of a brush.

(a) This discussion should probably be happening someplace other
than NANOG (spam-l or mailop, perhaps?), and

(b) If you feel that UCEProtect L3 paints with too broad a brush,
then you're certainly free not to use it. I happen to agree with you
on this particular level of this particular DNSBL for my particular
applications, so I don't use it either. However: I'm aware of other
folks who are using it quite effectively as *part* of a scoring system.

---Rsk

2

(a) This discussion should probably be happening someplace other
than NANOG (spam-l or mailop, perhaps?), and

True. I didn't bring it up but this is my last post on the subject.

(b) If you feel that UCEProtect L3 paints with too broad a brush,
then you're certainly free not to use it. I happen to agree with you
on this particular level of this particular DNSBL for my particular
applications, so I don't use it either. However: I'm aware of other
folks who are using it quite effectively as *part* of a scoring system.

I don't use it but my problem was that other ISPs whose clients were
trying to email my clients were using it.