In a unanimous vote today, the US Senate approved a bill which would
1) Cancel DST permanently, and
2) Move every square inch of US territory 15 degrees to the east.
My opinion of this ought to be obvious from my rhetoric. Hopefully, it will
fail, because it's likely to be the end of rational time worldwide, and even
if you do log in UTC, it will still make your life difficult.
I'm poleaxed; I can't even decide which grounds to scream about this on...
Hopefully, the House or the White House will be more coherent in their
decision on this engineering construct.
Ending DST is a really good idea.
Moving 15 degrees East not so much but let’s face it, the environmental impact statement will take forever to write
I don’t follow why cancelling DST has the effect of moving the US fifteen degrees to the east. Also, your subject line reads “permanent DST”, but from your language the bill will be permanent standard time.
I haven’t read the bill, but I’m hoping you can explain your position more clearly.
-mel via cell
Moving 15 degrees east would put Washington DC in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. This might not be a bad thing.
Permanent DST has the same effect as cancelling DST and moving all the timezones up one hour. Since timezones are roughly sliced every 15 degrees of … longitude?, hefting the physical US 15 degrees eastward would have the same effect on timezones as just a legal glitch to change them.
I think this is essentially the bill:
Not finding anything about 15 degrees.
The bill is "permanently move all US time zones one hour earlier (-8 thru -5 is
replaced permanently with -7 thru -4).
They are *calling it* "permanent DST", but that's not really what's happening,
in my engineering appraisal. Or my geopolitical one, but I don't lay claim
to professional opinions there.
But how will we remember to change the batteries in our smoke and CO2 detectors then?
360 / 24 = 15. Because we'd standardize on DST instead of the old
railroad time zones. It's a variation on the old saw about Congress
repealing the inconvenient laws of physics.
Apparently this also adjusted the calendar, making today 2022-04-01 ?
Well, it would create term limits
If Canada doesn’t do the same thing at the same time, it’ll be a real hassle, dealing with a change from -8 to -7 crossing the border between BC and WA, for instance. It has to be done consistently throughout North America.
Ok, so the fifteen degrees is bogus, nothing moves, and all that is really happening is standard time is ending. The OP here wins an award for “obfuscating reality”.
No sweat. Fixing all the systems to comply with the new time rules is billable
-mel via cell
The 15 degrees is kind of a joke. It means that "high noon", when the sun is at zenith, would occur roughly 15 degrees east of noon local clock time.
It's kind of like the meme showing a Native American saying, "Only a white man would cut a foot off of the top of a blanket, sew it on the bottom, and think he has a longer blanket."
We already have this problem with Arizona, which never changes time for the summer.
-mel via cell
Thanks for finding the clarification on this Ray.
I’m with the OP Jay that this will cause long term problems. The 15 degrees is not mentioned in the document just the change from “Standard Time” to “Daylight Time” permanently (they probably don’t even understand it is in 15 degree increments). This will cause problems in systems across many sectors. The entire world works on UTC + or - on a 15 degree scale. Except now the US which will be 15 degree scale -15 degrees. I doubt Canada, Central, or South Americas are going to follow this so the United States will always be 15 degrees off of what is considered “Standard Time” by the world.
The better solution would be to remove DST all together and tell everyone in the US to start work at 07:00 and get off work at 16:00 every day.
Interesting - AZ would join PDT as UTC-7. I wonder if they’d switch to line up with the rest of MDT.
What does Arizona do since you’re saying all of N America has to be the same?
That would be no different than crossing state lines where the time zone changes. I don't perceive a significant impact.
Folks for most systems, this is a change to a single file. Not a really hard thing to accomplish