In message <9503301600.AA01532@stick.NERSC.gov>, "Chris Dorsey (510)422-4474" w
I agree with Matt, if a network turns off LSRR, then
I try to hand them the ticket. However, it seems that
lots of sites either yield no human response at all, or
get back to you a few days later. Not very helpful in the
face of intermittent problems. So you're the one holding
the trouble ticket with no tools and no help.
I've thought a little about this over the past few
months as more sites shut off LSRR, and it seems like
a "ping" or "traceroute" server-client would really
come in handy. No human interaction needed, I just
request a ping/trace from site A going from A to B.
Has anyone explored this or is it a silly idea and
I'm being dense.
If LSRR is turned off somewhere, what I ussually do is the following
Start in the middle of your network (anywhere in 140.222 in our case)
and traceroute to both sites in question. For each direction:
Try a traceroute -g from end site A to end site B (traceroute -g A B).
If this never reaches end site A, presumably because LSRR is blocked,
then back up to the last router that responded (call it R1). Then
traceroute from R1 to B (traceroute -g R1 B). This will often end
slightly before B (call this R2). What this usually yields is:
/-->- hop hop hop -->-\
A ... R1 -<-- hop hop hop -<-- R2 ... B
--- you are here --
This is OK as long as R1 and R2 are very close to the site. They are
usually the provider router one hop from the firewall. There may be
an assymetric route, with one side going off into the black hole (this
is then the problem). There may be a symmetric or assymetric route
with a loss problem. Since you now know the route, you can now try
source routed ping and try to isolate the loss enough to know which
NOC to notify.
If the problem is loss between A and R1 or B and R2, then a regular
ping should show the problem.
The only case where this doesn't work is where the route from A to B
or B to A doesn't go through R1 and/or R2. There is no way to know
this for sure. I don't know of any IP providers that have turned off
LSRR on their backbone routers, just site routers.